SYS 478: Fall 2026

symposium project

Symposium 3: Develop Your Argument

Turn your research into a clear argument about your AI system and what it reveals about technology and society.

Due Fri, 10/30 at 11:59 PM

Part 3 of 5 on the way to the AI & Society Symposium (Nov. 17). Team deliverable, 10 points.

What You’re Doing

You’ve gathered evidence about your AI system. Now it’s time to decide what story you want to tell about it, and why that story matters.

Your goal is to develop a central argument that explains something important about your system: how it works, what human choices and priorities shape it, who is affected, and what larger issue it helps us understand.

Think of this as developing the story your exhibit will tell. By the end of this milestone, you should know what you want visitors to understand, what evidence supports your argument, and why it matters.

Questions to Guide Your Analysis

Use these questions to guide your thinking. You don’t need to answer each one separately, and not all of these questions may be relevant to your project.

  • Purpose: What is the system designed to do? Why was it developed, and whose needs or interests does it serve?
  • Design and priorities: How does it work? What choices, assumptions, or incentives shape how it operates?
  • People and power: Who develops, owns, uses, or controls the system? Who benefits, who might be harmed, and who can change how it works?
  • Consequences: What are the intended and unintended effects of this system? Who benefits, who might be harmed, and how?
  • Alternatives: What could be done differently? What tradeoffs would those changes involve?
  • Bigger picture: What does your system reveal about technology, society, power, or human values more broadly? Does what’s happening in your specific case connect to other things going on in the world?

Be careful to distinguish between what your evidence shows, what you’re arguing, and what remains uncertain.

What to Submit

Submit one document per team that includes:

  1. Your central argument (2–3 sentences). What does your research reveal about this system? What larger issue does it help us understand? What is the most important thing you want visitors to take away?

  2. A systems diagram. Show the important parts of your system, how they interact, and where human decisions or priorities shape what happens. Identify at least two important design choices or assumptions. A hand-drawn diagram is fine.

  3. Evidence and analysis. Use 2–3 findings from your research to support your argument. Explain how the system’s design, business model, or institutional context helps produce its outcomes. Who benefits, who might be harmed, and who has the power to make decisions? What remains uncertain?

  4. What could be different? Identify at least one way the system could be designed, used, or governed differently. Who could make that change? What tradeoffs might it involve?

  5. An initial exhibit idea. How might you communicate your argument to visitors in five minutes? Describe one thing visitors could see, do, or discover that would help them understand your main point. This is just a starting idea – you’ll develop it further in Milestone 4.

Submit your document on Canvas by the due date above.

Tips

  • Your argument can be tentative. It’s fine to revise it as you learn more.
  • You don’t need to argue that AI is good or bad, or that your system necessarily causes harm. Your argument should be grounded in evidence.
  • Focus on explaining why things happen, whose choices matter, and what could be different.
  • Keep your exhibit audience in mind. What would make someone stop, pay attention, and reconsider something they thought they understood?

What’s Next?

In Milestone 4: Design the Visitor Experience, you’ll turn your argument into a concrete exhibit plan, including a storyboard and an interactive element.

During our next class, you’ll share your systems diagram and give another team a three-minute explanation of your central argument and exhibit idea. They’ll tell you what they understood, what questions they still have, and what might make your story clearer.

Your goal is to leave this milestone with a clear idea of what you’re trying to say, so you can spend the next one figuring out how to show it.


Poster Templates and Design Resources

Poster size: 48 inches wide × 36 inches tall (landscape). You may customize any template, but the poster must keep the required analytical content: system, argument, evidence, societal implications, questions and possibilities, and references.

36 × 48-Inch Poster Templates

Additional Templates and Inspiration