symposium project
Symposium 2: Investigate the Evidence
Research how your system works and what is known about its effects, including what is uncertain or contested.
Due Fri, 10/23 at 11:59 PM
Part 2 of 5 on the way to the AI & Society Symposium (Nov. 17). Team deliverable, 10 points.
What You’re Doing
Research how your system works and what is known about its effects. Identify areas of uncertainty and competing interpretations.
- Four well-chosen, carefully read sources are more useful than ten skimmed ones. Choose sources you can explain, and say what each one lets you claim.
- As you research, keep returning to your central question from Part 1:
- How does the evidence help you answer it?
- Does anything you’ve discovered challenge your initial assumptions?
- Does your research question need to be revised?
- As you gather evidence, consider what your case might reveal about a larger social pattern, tension, or question. Are you finding evidence that supports, complicates, or challenges your initial ideas?
What To Submit
An evidence brief that includes:
- An annotated list of at least four credible sources, including original research where available. For each, note what it claims, how it knows, and how much you trust it.
- Three to five important findings or claims, each supported by evidence. Explain how each helps answer your central research question.
- At least one important limitation, disagreement, or unanswered question.
- A preliminary explanation of how the system works.
Submit one brief per team on Canvas by the due date shown above.
Tips
- Your final exhibit’s bibliography needs at least 10 credible sources, including two research-based or primary sources, so treat this list as the start.
- Separate established findings from predictions or speculation, and say which is which.
- Your conclusion does not have to be that the system is harmful. “The evidence is inconclusive” or “it depends on how it is used” are legitimate findings.
- You may revise your original question as you learn more.
Next class
During class next week, you will compare conflicting claims with another group, and decide what you can responsibly say. Be prepared to talk about what you have discovered, what surprised you, and what you still don’t know.
Your next task will be to use this evidence to develop an argument about how the system’s design, human choices, and social context shape its consequences.
Poster Templates and Design Resources
Poster size: 48 inches wide × 36 inches tall (landscape). You may customize any template, but the poster must keep the required analytical content: system, argument, evidence, societal implications, questions and possibilities, and references.
36 × 48-Inch Poster Templates
- UNC Asheville CrAFT Studio – Poster Design Resources – Templates for PowerPoint, Google Slides, Canva, and Keynote, including 36 × 48-inch formats.
- PosterScientist – Free Research Poster Templates – Customizable research poster layouts, including 36 × 48-inch options.
- Genigraphics – PowerPoint Poster Templates – Free editable PowerPoint templates in multiple sizes.
- PosterPresentations – Free Poster Templates – Various layouts and sizes, including 36 × 48 inches.
Additional Templates and Inspiration
- PosterNerd – Billboard Poster Templates – Argument-centered posters featuring a prominent takeaway supported by research.
- Canva – Research Poster Templates – Visually engaging, customizable templates. Check the dimensions and resize to 48 × 36 inches.
- Derek Crowe – Butter Poster – A research poster layout emphasizing clear communication and supporting evidence.
- Colin Purrington – Research Poster Design and Templates – Free templates and practical advice on organizing research posters.