Tue, Oct 13
Topic 4. Public Controversies: Institutions, Interests, and Evidence
AI for What? Progress, Benevolence, and Solutionism
Please complete the tasks and readings listed below before class on Tue, Oct 13.
Required Readings
Optional Readings
Reading
Gebru, T. (2022, May 26). Timnit Gebru keynote at UC Berkeley School of Information commencement 2022 [Video]. YouTube. Link
Reading
Gebru, T., & Torres, É. P. (2024). The TESCREAL bundle: Eugenics and the promise of utopia through artificial general intelligence. First Monday, 29(4). Link
Reading
Perrigo, B. (2022, January 18). Why Timnit Gebru isn’t waiting for Big Tech to fix AI’s problems. TIME. Link
Agenda
- Team Assignments. Go ahead and get into your groups.
- Introduction to the course resources:
- AI Deployment Patterns
- Some examples to get you thinking
- Research & Presentation Resources:
Some resources about different ways of getting people to think about deeper issues.
- Overview of the deliverables
- Team Agreement Activity - See Google Doc
Overarching Question: When is AI a meaningful solution to a problem, and when does it distract us from addressing the problem’s underlying causes?
Understanding the Main Arguments
- What does Morozov mean by technological solutionism? Why might it be appealing?
- How does Gebru challenge the idea that more powerful AI will necessarily lead to a better society?
- Both Morozov and Gebru challenge the idea that technological progress necessarily produces social progress. What would meaningful progress look like?
Applying the Ideas
When analyzing your technology, here are some important questions you can ask to figure out whether the technology is genuinely useful, whether it masks deeper issues, or both.
- What assumptions about people, society, or progress are built into the proposed technological solution?
- When might technological solutions reinforce the very problems they are intended to solve?
- How can we distinguish between problems that genuinely need better technology and problems that require political, economic, or institutional change?
- Is the alternative to technological solutionism rejecting technology? What might a more thoughtful approach to AI development look like?
Question for the Symposium
- Is your team investigating a problem that AI can solve, or a problem that AI itself helps create?